Home | Search | Help
OST by Number | OST by Order | OST by Carrier | OST by Subject | OST by Day
OIA by Carrier/Subject | OIA by Day | FAA by Number | FAA by Subject | FAA by Day
Carrier Financials | Charter Office | Answer/Reply Calendar


OST-2000-7856

http://www.flytheshoals.com/ - Northwest Alabama Regional Airport


EAS Docket



Essential Air Service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

OST-2000-7856 August 24, 2000 Notice of Intent to Terminate Service Terminate Air Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Express Airlines, Philip Reed, 901.348.4265, preed@nwairlink.com  



Order 00-10-3
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued October 2, 2000
Served October 5, 2000
Order Prohibiting Termination of Service and Requesting Proposals Terminate Air Service Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport, Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

By: Francisco Sanchez



Order 00-12-18
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued December 21, 2000
Served December 27, 2000
Order Extending Service Obligation Terminate Air Service Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport, Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

By: Randall Bennett



Order 00-1-16
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued January 22, 2001
Served January 25, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation Terminate Air Service Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

By: Randall Bennett



Order 01-2-12
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued February 14, 2001
Served February 20, 2001 
Order Extending Service Obligation Terminate Air Service Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

By: Randall Bennett



Order 01-03-21
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7857
Issued March 21, 2001
Served March 26, 2001
Order Selecting Carrier and Setting Final Rate 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Owensboro, KY / Muscle Shoals, AL / Jackson, TN

By:  Susan McDermott


Order 01-03-22
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued March 22, 2001
Served March 27, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Owensboro, KY / Muscle Shoals, AL / Jackson, TN

Order 2001-3-22 is extending Northwest Airlink's service obligation at Owensboro, Kentucky, Muscle Shoals, Alabama and Jackson, Tennessee, for an additional 30 days, through April 23, 2001.  

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 01-4-27
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
Issued April 20, 2001
Served April 25, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation Terminate Air Service Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

By: Randall Bennett



Order 01-05-16
OST-00-7856
Issued May 15, 2001
Served May 18, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Susan McDermott



OST-00-7856 May 22, 2001 Proposal of Corporate Airlines to Provide Essential Air Service for Muscle Shoals, AL (3 Round Trips)   90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Corporate Airlines



Order 01-6-21
OST-00-7856
Issued June 25, 2001
Served June 28, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 01-7-8
OST-00-7856
Issued July 13, 2001
Served July 18, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation EAS - 90-Day Notice to Terminate Service at Muscle Shoals, AL

On August 24, 2000, Express Airlines I, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink (Northwest Airlink), filed a 90-day notice of its intent to suspend its subsidy-free service at Owensboro, KY, Muscle Shoals, AL, and Jackson, TN, effective November 22, 2000. By Order 2000-10-3, October 2, 2000, the Department prohibited Northwest Airlink from suspending service at the communities for an initial 30-day period, through December 22, 2000, and stated that we would issue subsequent 30-day hold-in orders until we could secure replacement service. We recently issued Order 2001-3-21, selecting Corporate Airlines to provide service at Jackson and Owensboro. That service began on May 1, 2001. At Muscle Shoals, we have extended Northwest Airlink's service obligation for additional 30-day periods, the latest through July 23, 2001, by Order 2001-6-21.

Corporate has submitted a proposal to replace Northwest Airlink at Muscle Shoals. However, since this case will not be completed before the end of the current hold-in period, and as required by 49 U.S.C. 41734, we must continue to hold Northwest Airlink in at Muscle Shoals for an additional 30-day period.

By:  Randall Bennett



Essential Air Services At Muscle Shoals, AL; Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport; Jackson, TN; Topeka, Kansas; Alamogordo/Hollman AFB, New Mexico; Hot Springs and Jonesboro, Arkansas; Pueblo, Colorado; Hana, Hawaii; Kamuela, Hawaii; Augusta/Waterville; Oneida County Airport; Massena, New York; Enid, OK; Oil City/Franklin, Pennsylvania; Ponce, Puerto Rico; Oshkosh, Wisconsin

Order 01-8-9
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7855
OST-00-7857
OST-96-1352
OST-96-1901
OST-97-2935
OST-99-6589
OST-99-6502
OST-97-2833
OST-97-2784
OST-00-7556
OST-97-2842
OST-97-2401
OST-97-2523
OST-99-6592
OST-99-5712
Issued August 7, 2001
Served August 10, 2001
Statement of Proposed Policy Regarding Program Deductions Essential Air Services At Muscle Shoals, AL; Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport; Jackson, TN; Topeka, Kansas; Alamogordo/Hollman AFB, New Mexico; Hot Springs and Jonesboro, Arkansas; Pueblo, Colorado; Hana, Hawaii; Kamuela, Hawaii; Augusta/Waterville; Oneida County Airport; Massena, New York; Enid, OK; Oil City/Franklin, Pennsylvania; Ponce, Puerto Rico; Oshkosh, Wisconsin

Because a $50 million budget can no longer cover the program's current commitments, the Administration's budget proposal also includes a proposal to revise some of the standards under which communities are ineligible for subsidy-supported scheduled air service. Under the proposed revisions, communities would not be eligible if they are:

The statutory prohibition against continuing to subsidize communities requiring subsidy of more than $200 per passenger, except for exceptionally isolated points, would remain unchanged.  The proposed revisions would allow the Department to continue to meet its core obligation of ensuring that truly isolated communities continue to receive at least a minimum level of scheduled air service and thereby remain connected to the national air transportation system. At the same time, it would curtail spending for local service at communities that are within reasonable driving distances of service at other airports.

In light of the program's current spending rate and the Administration's budget proposal, we have decided to issue this statement of proposed policy now, to give the communities and carriers ample notice of the program reductions that we will implement in the event that Congress enacts them into law. Those reductions will result in the termination of subsidy at the 17 communities listed below as of October 1, 2001 -- the first day of fiscal year 2002 -- and will allow the carriers providing subsidized service at those communities to discontinue service on the same date, if they choose, without the need to provide individual notice. Implementation of the reductions at the very outset of the next fiscal year is necessary for program spending to remain within the proposed $50 million budget. Waiting to initiate the process until Congress has already acted could delay implementation of the reductions and require us to make even deeper program cuts, affecting more communities, in order to remain within our budgetary constraints.

By:  Susan McDermott



OST-00-7856 August 13, 2001 Corporate Airlines Proposal to Provide Essential Air Service Terminate Air Service at Muscle Shoals, AL

By:  Corporate Airlines

OST-00-7856 August 13, 2001 Community Response of Northwest Alabama Regional Airport Terminate Air Service at Muscle Shoals, AL

By:  Northwest Alabama Regional Airport, John Lehrter



Order 01-8-19
OST-00-7856
Issued August 22, 2001
Served August 27, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 01-9-08
OST-00-7856
Issued September 13, 2001
Served September 
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 01-10-10
OST-00-7856
Issued October 22, 2001
Served October 25, 2001 
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 01-11-7
OST-00-7856
Issued November 14, 2001
Served November 19, 2001
Order Extending Service Obligation EAS at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Read C. Van de Water



Order 01-12-17
OST-00-7856
Issued December 20, 2001
Served December 27, 2001 
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate EAS at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-1-01
OST-00-7856
Issued January 4, 2002
Served January 9, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



OST-00-7855
OST-00-7856
OST-00-7857
February 1, 2002
Docketed February 20, 2002
Request for Subsidy andEssential Air Service Proposal of Northwest Airlink, Express Airlines Terminate Air Serviceat Owensboro Davies County Regional Airport Northwest Alabama & Jackson, TN

As a result of the Department's Order 2000-10-3, Express Airlines I (Express 1) was compelled to provide essential air service at the above-captioned points and is entitled to subsidy for such service. With respect to Owensboro, Kentucky and Jackson, Tennessee, Express I is entitled to subsidy for essential air services provided beginning on November 22, 2000, the date upon which Express I's 90-day notice elapsed and Order 2000-10-3 compelled Express I to continue service, through April 30, 2001, the date upon which Express I terminated service pursuant to Order 2001-3-21, selecting Corporate Airlines, Inc. to provide replacement service effective May 1, 2001. With respect to Muscle Shoals, Alabama, Express I provided essential air service beginning November 22, 2000, pursuant to Order 2001-10-3, through February 21, 2002, pursuant to Order 2002-1-1. Attached are Express I's detailed subsidy reimbursement proposals for provision of the above-described services.

In addition, attached is Express I's subsidy proposal for continued essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, at a level of two or three roundtrip flights per day. Express I proposes to operate the proposed Muscle Shoals essential air service using 33-seat Saab 340 aircraft, as it does currently.

By:  Northwest Airlink, Curtis Sawyer



Order 02-2-15
OST-00-7856
Issued February 20, 2002
Served February 25, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation Terminate Air Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

On August 24, 2000, Express Airlines I, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink (Northwest Airlink), filed a 90-day notice of its intent to suspend its subsidy-free service at Owensboro, KY, Muscle Shoals, AL, and Jackson, TN, effective November 22, 2000. By Order 2000-10-3, October 2, 2000, the Department prohibited Northwest Airlink from suspending service at the communities for an initial 30-day period, through December 22, 2000, and stated that we would issue subsequent 30-day hold-in orders until we could secure replacement service. We issued

Order 2001-3-21, selecting Corporate Airlines to provide service at Jackson and Owensboro. That service began on May 1, 2001. At Muscle Shoals, we have extended Northwest Airlink's service obligation for additional 30-day periods, the latest through February 21, 2002, by Order 2002-1-1.

Corporate has submitted a proposal to replace Northwest Airlink at Muscle Shoals. However, since this case will not be completed before the end of the current hold-in period, and as required by 49 U.S.C. 41734, we must continue to hold Northwest Airlink in at Muscle Shoals for an additional 30-day period.

By:  Randall Bennett



OST-00-7856 February 21, 2002 Proposal "A" of Northwest Airlink Terminate Air Service Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Northwest Airlink, Curtis Sawyer


OST-00-7856 February 21, 2002 Proposal "B" of Northwest Airlink Terminate Air Service Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Northwest Airlink, Curtis Sawyer



OST-00-7856 February 27, 2002
Docketed March 11, 2002
Proposal to Provide Essential Air Service of Corporate Airlines Terminate Air Service Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Corporate Airlines



Order 02-3-17
OST-00-7856
Issued March 19, 2002
Served March 22, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service Muscle Shoals, Alabama

On August 24, 2000, Express Airlines 1, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink, filed a 90-day notice of its intent to suspend its subsidy-free service at Owensboro, KY, Muscle Shoals, AL, and Jackson, TN, effective November 22, 2000. By Order 2000-10-3, October 2, 2000, the Department prohibited Northwest Airlink from suspending service at the communities for an initial 30-day period, through December 22, 2000, and stated that we would issue subsequent 30-day hold-in orders until we could secure replacement service. We issued Order 2001-3-21, selecting Corporate Airlines to provide service at Jackson and Owensboro. That service began on May 1, 2001. At Muscle Shoals, we have extended Northwest Airlink's service obligation for additional 30-day periods, the latest through March 25, 2002, by Order 2002-2-15.

Both Northwest Airlink and Corporate Airlines have submitted subsidy proposals for service at Muscle Shoals. However, since this case will not be completed before the end of the current hold-in period, and as required by 49 U.S.C. 41734, we must continue to hold Northwest Airlink in at Muscle Shoals for an additional 30-day period.

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-4-15
OST-00-7856
Issued April 18, 2002
Served April 23, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-5-11
OST-00-7856
Issued May 14, 2002
Served May 17, 2002 
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Read Van de Water



Order 02-6-10
OST-00-7856
Issued June 18, 2002
Served June 21, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation Express Airlines I, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink - 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

On August 24, 2000, Express Airlines 1, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink (Northwest Airlink), filed a 90day notice of its intent to suspend its subsidy-free service at Owensboro, KY, Muscle Shoals, AL, and Jackson, TN, effective November 22, 2000. By Order 2000-10-3, October 2, 2000, the Department prohibited Northwest Airlink from suspending service at the communities for an initial 30day period, through December 22, 2000, and stated that we would issue subsequent 30-day hold-in orders until we could secure replacement service. We issued Order 2001-3-21, selecting Corporate Airlines to provide service at Jackson and Owensboro. That service began on May 1, 2001. At Muscle Shoals, we have extended Northwest Airlink's service obligation for additional 30-day periods, the latest through June 24, 2002, by Order 2002-5-11. Both Northwest Airlink and Corporate Airlines have submitted subsidy proposals for service at Muscle Shoals. However, since this case will not be completed before the end of the current hold-in period, and as required by 49 U.S.C. 41734, we must continue to hold Northwest Airlink in at Muscle Shoals for an additional 30-day period.

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-7-12
OST-00-7856
Issued July 8, 2002
Served July 11, 2002 
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Randall Bennett



Express Airlines I, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink and 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport; Essential Air Service at Thief River Falls, Minnesota, Watertown, South Dakota, Mason and Fort Dodge, Iowa and Mesa Airlines, Inc.

Order 02-7-38
OST-00-7856
OST-01-10642
OST-01-10644
OST-01-10682
OST-01-10684
Issued July 30, 2002
Served August 2, 2002 
Order Setting Final Rates 90-Day Notice of Intent to Terminate Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport and EAS at Thief River Falls, Minnesota, Watertown, SD, Mason and Fort Dodge, Iowa

By this order we are setting short-term final subsidy rates for Express Airlines I at Muscle Shoals and for Mesaba Airlines, Inc., both operating as Northwest Airlink, at Fort Dodge, Mason City, Thief River Falls, and Watertown for "hold-in" essential air service (EAS) until further Department action.

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-08-14
OST-00-7856
Issued August 15, 2002
Served August 20, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate Service at Northwest Alabama Regional Airport

By:  Randall Bennett



Order 02-09-19
OST-00-7856
Issued September 19, 2002
Served September 24, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation Essential Air Service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By:  Randall Bennett



OST-00-7856 August 30, 2002
Docketed October 21, 2002
Proposal of Corporate Airlines Proposal to Provide EAS for Muscle Shoals, Alabama

Proposal of Corporate Airlines, Inc. to Provide Essential Air Service for Muscle Shoals, AL.

By: Corporate Airlines, Inc.



Order 02-11-5
OST-00-7856
Issued November 13, 2002
Served November 18, 2002
Order Extending Service Obligation 90-Day Notice to Terminate Essential Air  Service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

By: Read Van de Water

By Order 2002-7-3 8, July 30, 2002, the Department established a short-term annual subsidy rate for Express's hold-in service at Muscle Shoals. The carrier subsequently changed its name to Pinnacle Airlines Corp (Pinnacle). The staff and carrier agreed to two-tiered annual rates of $1,172,033, effective November 22, 2000, through September 10, 2001, and $1,284,408, effective September 11, 2001, until further Department action. Mesaba Aviation (Mesaba), another Northwest Airlink carrier, took over the Muscle Shoals-Memphis route on September 2. 2002.

Although we have received proposals, this case will not be completed before the end of the current hold-in period, and, as required by 49 U.S.C. 41734, we must hold Mesaba in at Muscle Shoals for an additional 30-day period.



Order 02-12-21
OST-00-7856
Issued December 30, 2002
Served January 3, 2003
Order Selecting Carrier

Word Document

Essential Air Service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama

We have decided to select Mesaba to provide subsidized EAS at Muscle Shoals for a new two-year period, commencing on the first day of the month following the service date of this order.  While we have taken into consideration the community’s preference for Corporate, the core purpose of the EAS program, since its inception in 1978 with the passage of the Airline Deregulation Act, is to ensure that each eligible community receives access to the nation’s air transportation system.  In this case, we find that both carriers are fully capable of providing reliable EAS.  Each carrier has a code-sharing relationship with a major carrier at its hub, each would serve a major hub airport, and each has an excellent record of serving small communities.  Mesaba would offer larger, 34-seat aircraft while Corporate would offer an additional round trip, but with 19-seaters.  Given the fact that each carrier would afford significant service benefits to passengers at Muscle Shoals, we believe that the almost $300,000 difference in subsidy cost weighs decisively in favor of the selection of Mesaba.  While the community would prefer higher frequency service to St Louis, albeit with smaller aircraft, we do not believe that the difference between the applicants’ proposed service justifies the expenditure that would be required to select Corporate’s proposal.  We will therefore select Mesaba to serve Muscle Shoals for a two-year period at the proposed subsidy rate of $1,284,408 per year.  Service will consist of two round trips on weekdays and three on weekends to Memphis with 34-seat, Saab 340 aircraft.

By:  Read C. Van de Water



Order 04-12-02
OST-00-7856 - EAS at Muscle Shoals, AL

Issued December 1, 2004 | Served December 6, 2004

Order Requesting Proposals | Word

By this order, the Department is requesting proposals from carriers interested in providing essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2005. We expect proposals consisting of service, at a minimum, with two-pilot, twin-engine aircraft with at least 15 passenger seats, and offering 13 round trips a week to Memphis, or another suitable hub.  Such service is consistent with what the community currently receives, and generally satisfies its essential air service requirements

By: Karan Bhatia



January 5, 2005

Proposal of Mesa Air Group d/b/a Air Midwest to Provide Essential Air Service

Mesa Air Group, Inc. d/b/a Air Midwest is pleased to submit a proposal to provide Essential Air Service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama. Mesa's proposed option would involve air service to Nashville.

All operations proposed would utilize our modem fleet of Raytheon/Beecheraft B‑1900D airliners. These aircraft offer a very comfortable 19‑seat, pressurized cabin with two turboprop engines. Mesa has a long history of offering Essential Air Service throughout the country, from Arizona to New York. Mesa plans on operating the service as Mesa Airlines, while pursuing all available options for future code share opportunities in Nashville.

We believe that Nashville, with a large presence from Southwest Airlines, is a much more cost effective hub for our customers to fly thru than Memphis. That, tied together with Mesa's commitment to providing its communities with a cost effective ticket, will hopefully facilitate an increase in passengers in Muscle Shoals throughout the term of the EAS contract.

By: Ed Wegel


January 5, 2005

Re: Proposal of Mesaba d/b/a Northwest Airlink

In response to the Department's Order 2003-12-2, Mesaba Aviation, Inc, doing business as Northwest Airlink, is enclosing its detailed subsidy proposal for continued essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, at a level of two roundtrip flights per day, using 34‑seat Saab 340 aircraft. The following is the current and proposed schedule:

Depart MEM

Arrive MSL

Depart MSL

Arrive MEM

09:45

10:48

 11:50

12:45

1455

15:38

 16:30

17:24

Northwest Airlink carriers have long provided scheduled service between Muscle Shoals and Northwest Airlines, Inc.'s hub in Memphis, Tennessee, and we welcome the opportunity to continue providing essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama for the two‑year period beginning February 1, 2005.

By: John Spanjers



December 20, 2004

OST-00-7856 - EAS at Muscle Shoals, AL

Re: Shoals Chamber of Commerce Letter in Support of Northwest Airlink

By: Stephen Holt



January 18, 2005

Re: Northwest Alabama Regional Airport Letter Approving Proposal of Mesaba

Mesa Air Group's proposal involves a significantly smaller aircraft, no code share, and an airport from which no air carrier operates a hubbing operation‑ These issues will significantly decrease use of local air service and, the Board does not believe Mesa Air Group's proposal meets the air travel needs of the Shoals community

By: Ed Borden


January 19, 2005

Re: The City of Muscle Shoals Letter in Support of Mesaba

Our entire city council was unanimous along with other entities in the Shoals Area in support of Mesaba Aviation Inc. dib/a/ as Northwest Air Link. We are happy with the aircraft, the dependability and the code share capability with Northwest Airlines. We believe that this is the best fit and service for our region. We would also like to continue conversation and any assistance on an earlier or later flight to grow our service boarding.

By: David Bradford, Mayor



January 31, 2005

Re: Resolution Adopted by City of Florence, AL

By: Robert Leyde



January 26, 2005

Re: Resolution Supporting Northwest Airlink by The City of Sheffield

By: Billy Anderson



Order 2005-02-11
OST-00-7856 - EAS at Muscle Shoals, AL

Issued February 16, 2005 | Served February 22, 2005

Order Reselecting Carrier and Establishing Subsidy Rates

By this order, the Department is re-selecting Mesaba Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide subsidized essential air service for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2005, at an annual rate of $1,364,697.

Air Midwest's proposed service to Nashville would not be provided under a codeshare arrangement and, thus, would not offer the Muscle Shoals community similar benefits.

We have always given great weight to the applicants' relative subsidy requirements. Here, Mesaba's proposal requires $184,000 more in subsidy than Air Midwest's. While we recognize that the two service proposals are not identical (Mesaba's would, e.g., offer service with a larger aircraft), and that Mesaba's subsidy is only six percent higher than the current rate, we are concerned about the higher cost of Mesaba's proposal. Nonetheless, we conclude that the higher costs of Mesaba's proposal do not outweigh the other factors, described above, all of which point toward the selection of Mesaba. We expect the community to continue to work diligently with Mesaba in an effort to raise traffic levels and, thus, reduce future subsidy requirements.

By: Karan Bhatia



Order 2006-3-16
OST-2000-7856

Issued March 21, 2006 | Served March 24, 2006

Order Approving Alternate Service Pattern

By Order 2005-2-11, the Department re-selected Mesaba Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide two nonstop round trips on weekdays (three over the weekend) to Memphis with 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2005, at an annual rate of $1,364,697.

On March 16, 2006, Mesaba requested that it be allowed to replace one of the nonstop round trips with two one-stop round trips for the same subsidy rate. In addition, under Mesaba’s proposal, the carrier would overnight the aircraft at Muscle Shoals, thereby providing an early morning departure from Muscle Shoals to Memphis, via Tupelo. By letters dated March 16, 2006, the Mayor and airport manager of Muscle Shoals fully support Mesaba’s proposal, each stating “[We] wholeheartedly support Northwest’s new schedule and look forward to working with Northwest Airlink to make this a successful venture.”

The Department approves the alternate service pattern requested by Mesaba Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama.

we will allow Mesaba to replace one of its weekday nonstop round trips with two one-stop (at Tupelo) round trips. On weekends, Mesaba may replace any or all (or none) of its three non-stops with one-stops. From a billing standpoint, we will compensate Mesaba’s one-stop flights at one-half the nonstop rate of $1,040.96 established in Order 2005-2-11, or $520.48.

By: Todd Homan



March 16, 2006

Support of Northwest Airlines:

On behalf of the entire Shoals area, we wholeheartedly supports Northwest's new schedule and looks forward to working with Northwest Airlink to make this a successful venture.



Order 2006-8-10
OST-2000-7856

Issued August 11, 2006 | Served August 16, 2006

Order Requesting Proposals

By Order 2005-2-11, February 16, 2005, the Department selected Mesaba Aviation, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide essential air service at Muscle Shoals for the two-year period ending January 31, 2007, by operating 13 nonstop round trips a week to Memphis with 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft at a subsidy of $1,364,697 annually. Recently, by Order 2006-3-16, March 21, 2006, the Department approved an alternate service pattern, proposed by Mesaba and supported by the community, to replace one nonstop round trip on weekdays with two one-stop round trips via Tupelo, Mississippi, and each of any number of the three nonstop round trips on weekends with two one-stop round trips via Tupelo, at the same annual subsidy.

As the end of the current rate term approaches, we are here requesting proposals from carriers interested in providing service at Muscle Shoals, with or without subsidy, for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2007. Carriers should file their proposals within 30 days of the date of service of this order.

With respect to Muscle Shoals specifically, we expect proposals consisting of service, at a minimum, with two-pilot, twin-engine aircraft offering at least 15 passenger seats. The community's essential air service determination, as last established by Order 1994-5-6, May 6, 1994, required a minimum of two nonstop or one-stop round trips each weekday and weekend to either Atlanta or Memphis, providing a total of at least 50 inbound and outbound seats. Consequently, we are here requesting proposals contemplating 18 round trips a week with 19-seat aircraft, or at least 12 round trips a week for larger aircraft, such as Mesaba currently operates, to Atlanta, Memphis, or some other suitable hub.

By this order, the Department is requesting proposals from carriers interested in providing essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2007.

By: Todd Homan



September 14, 2006

Proposals of Mesaba Airlines

In response to the Department’s Order 2006-8-10, Mesaba Aviation, Inc., doing business as Northwest Airlink, is enclosing two detailed subsidy proposals for essential air service at Muscle Shoals, AL.

Option #1 - a level of two roundtrip, non-stops per day using 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft from Northwest’s MEM hub:

Depart MSL Arrive MEM Depart MEM Arrive MSL
1155 1251 0940 1033
1625 1719 1450 1543

Option #2 - a level of three roundtrip flights per weekday (M-F) and two roundtrip per day on weekends (Sat/Sun), using 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft from Northwest’s MEM hub. One weekday flight to/from MSL would be non-stop to MEM, while the remaining flights to/from MSL would have a brief stop in TUP going both directions.

Depart MSL Arrive TUP Arrive MEM Depart MEM Arrive TUP
0600 0637 0744 0945
1155 1257 1415 1510
1622 1649 1756 1940 2027

By: Mesaba, Thomas Schmidt


September 19, 2006

DOT Letter to Mayor of Muscle Shoals Requesting Comments

As you know, by Order 2006-8-10, August 11, 2006, the Department requested proposals from carriers interested in providing scheduled air service at Muscle Shoals, with or without subsidy, for a new two-year period beginning February 1, 2007.

In response to our request, we have received a proposal from one carrier, Mesaba Aviation, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink.

We would appreciate receiving your final comments on Mesaba's proposal before we make our recommendation to the Assistant Secretary. We ask that you submit your comments within two weeks of receipt of this letter.

By: Dennis DeVany



October 2, 2006

City of Muscle Shoals in Support of Northwest Airlink Option 2

I am requesting that the U.S. Department of Transportation approve option 2. We believe that we are increasing our boarding using this schedule and continue to have a good relationship with Mesaba d/b/a Northwest Airlink. We have our first clients at the Shoals research Airpark and need commercial passenger air service.

By: Mayor David Bradford



Order 2006-11-12
OST-2000-7856

Issued November 15, 2006 | Served November 20, 2006

Order Selecting Carrier and Establishing Subsidy Rate

By this order, the Department is selecting Mesaba Aviation, Inc. d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide essential air service at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, for a new two-year period beginning February 1, 2007, at a subsidy of $1,504,929 annually. The choice is clear, since Option 2 is preferred by the community and requires less subsidy.

By: Andrew Steinberg



Order 2008-9-4
OST-2000-7856

Issued September 2, 2008 | Served September 5, 2008

Order Requesting Proposals

As the end of the current rate term approaches, in order to provide sufficient time to complete the carrier-selection process before the current contract expires, we are here requesting proposals from carriers interested in providing service at Muscle Shoals, with or without subsidy support, for the two-year period beginning February 1, 2009. Carriers should file their proposals no later than October 1.

Proposals should offer service with sufficient capacity to accommodate historical levels of traffic and, at a minimum, should be provided with two-pilot, twin-engine aircraft with at least 15 passenger seats. Specifically for Muscle Shoals, we are requesting proposals for service consisting of three round trips a day (18 a week) to Memphis or any other suitable hub with connections to the national air transportation system with 19-seat aircraft or two round trips a day (12 or 13 a week) with 30-seat or larger aircraft. Further, if carriers propose to serve Muscle Shoals with an intermediate stop (as Mesaba currently does via Tupelo), we would consider authorizing subsidy for an additional round trip.

By: Todd Homan



September 25, 2008

Re: Proposal of Mesaba Airlines

In response to the Department's Order 2008-9-4, Mesaba Aviation, Inc., doing business as Northwest Airlink, is enclosing a detailed subsidy proposal for essential air service at Muscle Shoals, AL. The proposal represents the current level of three roundtrip flights per weekday and two roundtrip flights per day on weekends, using 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft from Northwest's MEM hub. One weekday flight to/from MSL would be non-stop to MEM, while the remaining flights to/from MSL would have a brief stop in TUP going both directions.

Depart MSL
Arrives TUP
Arrive MEM
Depart MEM
Arrive TUP
Arrive MSL
0555 0640 0748 0940 1043
1155 1257 1415 1510 1602
1622 1649 1801 1940 2027 2124

By: Mesaba, John Spanjers



October 2, 2008

Re: Request for Community Comments of:

Mayor of City of Muscle Shoals, AL
Northwest Alabama Regional Airport Manager

As you know, by Order 2008-9-4, issued September 2, 2008, the Department solicited proposals from air carriers interested in providing essential air service at Muscle Shoals in anticipation of the end of the current contract on January 31, 2009. At this stage, we would normally ask for your preferences for various carriers and service options. However, in response to that order, Mesaba Aviation, Inc. was the only carrier to submit a proposal. Nonetheless, we want to give you an opportunity to submit any final comments for the record that you may have before we make a carrier-selection recommendation.

Mesaba (the incumbent) proposes to continue to operate 19 round trips a week to Memphis International Airport with 34-seat Saab 340 aircraft, at the annual subsidy rate of $1,782,928. Additionally, Mesaba would continue to operate one weekday flight on a nonstop basis, and the remainder of the flights would be operated with an intermediate stop at Tupelo, Mississippi. Mesaba's service is operated as Northwest Airlink, under a codeshare agreement with Northwest Airlines.

My purpose in writing to you at this time is to give you an opportunity to submit any final comments you might have on the carrier's subsidy proposal. We request that you review this information as expeditiously as possible and submit any comments you may have as soon as possible, but in any case no later than October 21, 2008.

By: Dennis DeVany



October 7, 2008

Re: City of Muscle Shoals in Support of Mesaba Airlines

On behalf of the City of Muscle Shoals, I am pleased to submit this Letter of Support for the proposal submitted by Mesaba Airlines (Northwest Airlink) for services with three daily flights to Memphis under the Essential Air Service Program.

By: Mayor, David Bradford


October 9, 2008

Re: Comments of City of Muscle Shoals

Northwest Airlines has proposed that the following schedule be enacted and continue operations through Northwest Airlink Service to the Northwest Alabama Regional Airport in Muscle Shoals, AL

Depart MSL
Arrive TUP
Arrive MEM
Depart MEM
Arrive TUP
Arrive MSL
0555 0640 0748 0940 1043
1155 1257 1415 1510 1602
1622 1649 1801 1940 2027 2124

By: Mayor, David Bradford



Order 2008-10-17
OST-2000-7856

Issued and Served October 16, 2008

Order Selecting Carrier

By this order, the Department is re-selecting Mesaba Airlines, Inc., d/b/a Northwest Airlink, to provide essential air service at annual subsidy rate of $1,782,928 at Muscle Shoals, Alabama, through January 31, 2011.

Mesaba was the only carrier to submit a bid. It proposes to continue to operate the same service pattern as we selected in Order 2006-11-2, but requests $277,999 additional annual subsidy for this service.

By: Michael Reynolds



October 21, 2008

Re: Lauderdale County Commission Letter in Support for Mesaba

On behalf of the Lauderdale County Commission, I am pleased to submit this letter of support for the proposal of Mesaba Airlines (Northwest Airlink). The proposal provides three daily flights to Memphis from Muscle Shoals under the Essential Air Service program. 

Lauderdale County and the Shoals Area are experiencing a notable period of economic development and growth and now, more than ever, needs reliable, affordable, and convenient air service. We are confident that, as our area grows, our boardingg from the Northwest Alabama Regional Airport will grow as well.

By: LCC, Dewey Mitchell



October 7, 2008

Re: City of Muscle Shoals in Support of Mesaba

On behalf of the City of Muscle Shoals I am pleased to submit this Letter of Support for the proposal submitted by Mesaba Airlines (Northwest Airlink) for services with three daily flights to Memphis under the Essential Air Service Program.

By: Mayor David Bradford


October 23, 2008

Email Message - Support Letter of Northwest Alabama Regional Airport Board

On behalf of the Northwest Alabama Regional Airport Board and the cities of Florence, Sheffield, Muscle Shoals and Tuscumbia, AL including the respective counties served, I submit this request for your support for the Essential Air Service Program serving our area.

By: Ed Borden


Home | Search | Help
OST by Number | OST by Order | OST by Carrier | OST by Subject | OST by Day
OIA by Carrier/Subject | OIA by Day | FAA by Number | FAA by Subject | FAA by Day
Carrier Financials | Charter Office | Answer/Reply Calendar